I’ve been searching around the web for awhile now trying to find decent movie archiving software for my pretty hefty collection. I tested out a few, but ended up coming back to All My Movies because it was the only one that met all the criteria I was looking for:
-A simple, intuitive interface
-Downloads information from IMDb (specifically Director, Plot Description, IMDb User Rating, and Year)
-Allows you to specify format besides DVD (specifically movies on CD)
-DVD covers. It seems AMM has the highest resolution auto-downloaded covers, and also shows screenshots (which I didn’t think was a big deal) but really appreciate now for getting a more accurate “feel” of a movie while perusing.

Also nice is when you click on any detail in the movie information field, there’s the option to then sort all movies that share that criteria - like specific genre, director, rating, etc.

I tested Collectorz Movie Collector, DVDProfiler, Movie Organizer, and a few others but they were more intensive, muddled, and didn’t always have the options or graphics I wanted.