NEWS CATEGORIES:



NEWS ARCHIVE >>
SOFTPEDIA REVIEWS >>
MEET THE EDITORS >>
Home / News / Reviews / Linux software reviews

Linux software reviews


ManDVD Review

A good-looking and easy to use video DVD creator.

By Mihai Marinof, Linux Editor

12th of April 2007, 13:42 GMT

Adjust text size:



ManDVD by ManDVD Team See editor's ratings
Version reviewed: ManDVD 2.4

ManDVD is a program to simply create DVD Video.

Features:

Requires:
· DVD Slideshow >= 0.7.5
· mencoder
· mplayer
· xine > 0.99.4
· lame >= 3.97
· dvdauthor >= 0.6.11
· mjpegtools >= 1.8.0
· netpbm >= 10.29
· transcode >= 1.0.2
· dvd+rw-tools >= 5.21.4



Download ManDVD
Request a review

ManDVD Logo
Enlarge picture
In the last couple of years, multimedia support in Linux has evolved quite nicely. Nowadays, modern distributions provide software for playing, editing or remastering video and audio files, several cool games with complex and modern graphics have already got released and I'm sure many more will follow. At this evolving rate, it shouldn't take very long until Linux will provide at least the same level of multimedia support as Windows or, why not, even excel it.

The newest addition to my multimedia software collection is a tool for generating video DVDs from video files on the hard drive. It also supports various useful features such as DVD menu creator, subtitle management, several video effects and more. Let's see.

Before anything, you'll need to install ManDVD. This isn't a hard thing to accomplish as the author has provided a binary package that should run on any distribution. Unfortunately, using ManDVD will require a pretty long list of requirements, which are listed at the top of this review. To enjoy all the features of this program, you'll need to open your distribution's package manager and start looking for each package, install it and only then run ManDVD.

When running ManDVD for the first time, it will greet you with a dialog which asks you to choose a language. After selecting the language you know best from that list, you'll notice a second dialog. Unlike the first one, this will pop-up every time you run ManDVD and will ask you to choose a destination folder for the DVD project, where the AUDIO_TS and VIDEO_TS folders will reside, a video standard you want to use (PAL or NTSC) and size. The video size drop-down menu only provides four resolutions, 720x576, 704x480, 352x576 and 352x288. From the same dialog, you can load an existing project.

After confirming the second dialog, ManDVD will show its interface in all its grace. In fact, its interface is really a large and complex wizard and this is the first step: adding media. The upper part of the window consists of the program's name and version in the left and a logo in the right. The rest of the window is divided in two sections: in the upper left, there's a slick preview box which looks like a small monitor bolted into the application. Underneath the preview will be listed the media files added for processing. Each file in this list will have an icon right next to it. What the icons mean is listed in the lower left part of the first step. If the file's icon
is black and white, it means 'Video not reencoded', while the sepia icon points out a reencoded file. Now for the right part: it provides a menu divided in categories. The first category, 'Add or Modify Media Stream' contains buttons for adding a video, modify the title, remove the selected video and create the slideshow. Other categories include 'Editing and Adjustments' for cutting film parts, defining chapters, managing subtitles and video effects and 'Other' for adding an interactive video to the DVD. The lowest part of the step is reserved for various information, such as total file size, video format and in path. There are also two buttons, 'Save project' and 'NEXT' which guides us to the next step, 'Menu parameters'

In the next step, you'll customize the appearance of your DVD menu. You can create and modify the DVD menu background, buttons, fonts style and color. Moreover, you can choose a sountrack for you main menu. The image set as background can be mirrored horizontally or vertically, or applied a negative or sepia color effect.

Third step leads to menu creation. For each video and/or chapter created in the first step, you can add a button in the DVD menu. Each button can be resized and repositioned, or cleaned-up if you want to start over. Moreover, you can define the order in which the items are selected on your menu by clicking the 'Tab order' button in the lower right. Underneath it, there's another button named 'Mask edit' which leads to another screen. Here, you will be able to manage the selected or clicked mask by adding or removing lines or text. I'm not sure what this feature is for, but I think everything you add will appear on top of the button, in the DVD menu.

In the final step, your DVD will be generated. First, click the Options button at the bottom and choose a video bitrate and the subtitle font, size, location and charset. You can also choose whether to deinterlace the video and where to start reading the DVD from. Pressing the Options button again will return to the previous screen. Now from the right menu, select a format (4:3 or 16:9), the execution priority and you are ready to click the Generate DVD structure button. During encoding, you may press the show /hide console bottom to see a detailed output of what is going on under the hood. When the process is complete, several buttons will be revealed: Watch the result (using xine), Burn DVD, Burn DVD with K3b and Create an ISO image.

The Good

ManDVD is a multimedia application for creating video DVDs. Its interface is very clean and easy to use and allows creating a full-featured DVD in a very short time. Besides creating DVDs, ManDVD can also generate slideshows from images and provides basic features for editing the video file before encoding into the DVD structure.

The Bad

Unfortunately, ManDVD has a few downsides: it has no help system, the interface isn't totally translated in English and the red/green colors in Mask Edit can't be changed (or I didn't find out how)

The Truth

Well designed application. It's stable, very easy to use and has a clean, nice interface. Definitely worth trying!


Check out some screenshots below:
Review imageReview imageReview imageReview image
Review imageReview imageReview imageReview image
Review imageReview imageReview imageReview image

EDITOR'S RATINGS:

User Interface:
Features:
Ease of use:
Pricing/Value:
Overall:
  Final verdict: Very good

TAGS:

DVD | create | video | edit
Read by 20,417 user(s) | Add comment | Link to this article TWEET THIS


Article rating:
Excellent (5.0/5) 2 vote(s)    

Subscribe to news | Print article | Send to friend

© Copyright 2001-2009 Softpedia
Contact:

 

 

SEARCH THE NEWS ARCHIVE :




Today's News
| Yesterday's News | News Archive


MORE RELATED ARTICLES:

User opinions:


Comment #1 by: Ian Sinclair on 20 Sep 2008, 10:27 GMT reply to this comment

Great-looking application, but it changed a 3.1GB video file, extracted from a DVD, into 7.5GB of VOB files . By contrast, teh DeVeDe 3.11 program converted without increase in size.


Comment #2 by: steve on 15 Jan 2009, 21:58 GMT reply to this comment

The mask option that the reviewer above was confused by is supposed to allow you to edit the overlay that appears on a menu choice when it is selected by the person viewing it. Unfortunately in the version of ManDVD I ran (2.4.5) this editing function doesn't work well.

I tried to draw a green vertical line slightly to the right of the selected menu choice using the freehand line tool and maximum line width. While it did appear in the mask editor, it didn't appear in the finished DVD menu.

I also found that, despite the suggestion at the end of the program, de-interlacing was NOT required by LCD TVs, but it did interfere with conventional CRT TVs. So de-interlacing should probably not be used unless you have a special requirement.

I also found that re-encoding DID need to be enabled in the Options menu just before generating the final DVD. Otherwise, my version of ManDVD seemed to get stuck during DVD generation.

Another hoped for feature in the future, if anyone continues development of this application, would be a feature to allow group modification of all slides in the slideshow section. At present you have to set the duration and transition of each slide individually.

Finally, I found that you could not save a project after you started the Menu generation process. You could only save it before that point. If your DVD did not work out the way you wanted it, you had to start back at the menu creation stage again. It would be nice to be able to go back and edit your last menu or change a leter DVD generation option without having to start all over again.

All in all this is a really nice program that needs a little more work to make it truly easy to use.

Share your opinion:

Your Name:
Your Email Address:
(will not be used for commercial purposes)
Solve this to prove you're not a bot: =
Your review/opinion:

 




Windows tabGames tabDrivers tabMac tabLinux tabScripts tabMobile tabHandheld tabGadgets tabNews tab

SUBMIT PROGRAM   |   ADVERTISE   |   GET HELP   |   SEND US FEEDBACK   |   RSS FEEDS   |   ENTER NEWS SITE   |   ENGLISH BOARD   |   ROMANIAN FORUM