Softpedia
 

NEWS CATEGORIES:



NEWS ARCHIVE >>
SOFTPEDIA REVIEWS >>
MEET THE EDITORS >>
Home > News > Reviews > Windows software reviews

January 26th, 2009, 18:53 GMT · By

PerfectDisk 10

SHARE:

Adjust text size:



PerfectDisk by Raxco Software See editor's ratings     Request a review
Version reviewed: PerfectDisk 10 Build 93

PerfectDisk combines speed, thoroughness, flexibility, control and ease-of-use to help improve PC and server performance. It ensures that your Windows 2008, Vista, Windows Server 2003, Windows XP, Windows 2000, and Windows Home Server systems maintain the best possible performance.


Download PerfectDisk
Features:

Smart automatic StealthPatrol
Complete space management reports
Faster Free Space Consolidation
AutoPilot Scheduling
Pause feature
Free Space Management
Cumulative counters

PerfectDisk 10 splash screen
Enlarge picture
Some of you already know that after a while the files on the disk become fragmented. This happens because new data is stored in the first free piece of space available. If the file is larger than the first free space chunk found it will be fragmented and scattered in other free spaces until storage is complete. As a result of this administration your operating system will take longer to access fragmented files as it has to put more effort into finding all the scattered pieces.

And if the fragmented drive happens to be the system partition then the entire working with the computer turns into a real drag. Windows brings an automated defragmentation method but it is just a basic tool that cannot optimize the disks thoroughly.

We've already made a round-up of the new features of the upcoming PerfectDisk 10, which is one of the most appreciated defragmentation tools at the time. It has stirred more and more interest with each release as reliance on its performance combined with the utmost ease of use and a complete set of scheduling options improved beyond the power of most competitors.

Regarding its ascension, this year's PerfectDisk 10 is no different than the one launched last year. It brings the goods to the table under the form of an improved defragmentation engine that moves up to 30% faster, a pause button that lets you suspend defragmentation for as much time as you need, idle state defragmentation and space management reports.

The interface has not changed a lot but the minor details that have been added or modified certainly make for an improvement. Structure-wise the options and functions are still there but there are new elements finely integrated. A keen eye will definitely observe the new items among the old assortment of options as well as the slightly different separation of the menus.

Once PerfectDisk 10 is installed and launched it will provide a brief configuration wizard to set it up as it best fits your needs. It comprises two steps that include choosing between a notebook or desktop configuration of the program (here you can enable defragmentation of USB, firewire connected hard drives and flash drives) and creating the first defragmentation schedule and specifying when it should be enabled.

Just like in the previous version of PerfectDisk, the Defragmentation menu window is split into three distinct panels: the upper part is occupied with menu options, the middle part contains all detected drives and the lower side provides results and statistics.

Review image Review image Review image


The three defragmentation methods have been preserved, with SMARTPlacement (optimizes file placement and performs one-pass free space consolidation) leading the way, followed by consolidation of free space (aggressive free space consolidation) and simple defragmentation (defrags all fragmented files).

Every detail is broken down in an understandable form for any type of user to see exactly the fragmentation level and its impact on drive performance. The drive map is sometimes not enough for this so PerfectDisk makes available graphical statistics for comparing drive performance and free space file fragmentation before and after the intervention of PerfectDisk.

The Statistics view in the lower part of the interface provides a pervasive look over all factors contributing to the drive's performance degradation, from file and directory fragmentation status to free space and system file fragmentation. The performance level of the partition is also present. Additional data collected by the application includes a list of the most fragmented items (with the possibility of fixing them up individually), performance and free space charts.

PerfectDisk 10 allows you to defragment individual files on a selected drive and the option is to be found in the Defragmentation view (Selected Files option). You will be presented with a list of all the drives and you can choose off each one which items should be defragged. To make it easier on you the application can show only the fragmented elements.

System files cannot be dealt with while the OS is loaded but PerfectDisk is utterly capable of performing both online and offline defragmentation. You can set the minimum fragmentation level accepted before PerfectDisk starts the optimization procedure as well as make the SMARTPlacement settings. SMARTPlacement is a finer way to control the data that should be accessed the fastest from a partition. It will actually move the file to the fast-access tracks of the hard disk.

While on the job, PerfectDisk displays in Drive Map the file it is currently moving around as well as the current status of the defragmentation in percentages. It will also estimate the time to complete the given mission. However, I would not rely on this too much as during our testing the times showed for more ample jobs were almost always inaccurate (they kept modifying) or off the track. One time it happened for the estimation to freeze at a certain time and for the defragmentation to run at least 20 minutes more (the task was stopped before completion).

Review image Review image Review image Review image Review image
Review image Review image Review image Review image Review image


As you can see from the images below, we have given the best of us to create PerfectDisk 10's worst nightmare by creating a partition with as elevated a number of fragments as possible. 93.6% file fragmentation combined with 45.5% directory fragmentation and leaving 56KB as the largest free space chunk was the best we could accomplish. The total amount of free space on the drive was a little over 18MB.

Given the insufficient amount of free space, the application could not perform a SMARTPlacement defrag but running the simple defragmentation procedure or free space consolidation showed the efficiency of the software. After about 20 minutes of free space consolidation PerfectDisk reduced the percentage of fragments from 93.6% to 84.5%. Despite the small difference this should by all means not be neglected given the shape of the partition.

A couple of hours of simple defrag later, with 72% of the task completed, fragmentation level dropped to 47.8%. And it kept on dropping to 9.4% when it stopped due to insufficient space to complete the job. A second defragmentation increased performance even more, to 99.7%, reducing fragmentation level to 0.4%.

Before defragmentation
Enlarge picture
After defragmentation
Enlarge picture

AutoPilot Scheduling is where all future tasks are planned. The application brings a complete set of choices covering one-time, daily or weekly schedules. And these are just the regular plans because PerfectDisk 10 can also run its optimization procedure at idle times. Planning such a task can take into account the initialization of the screensaver or simply the idle time duration of a drive.

Although planning future operations may seem like a stroll in the park, PerfectDisk makes available wizard-assisted set-ups as scheduling takes into account a set of factors generally neglected by most apps of the same feather. Thus, in case multiple-drive defragmentation is desired ,you have the choice of selecting if the partitions should be defragged in series (one after another) or in parallel (all at the same time). Another step in the process involves enabling the recovery of free space (empty Recycle Bin and temporary file folders), choosing a defragmentation method and enabling offline defrag as well (this includes MFT, Metadata, Hibernate and Paging files).

Of course, offline process is unavailable in the case of screensaver scheduling and StealthPatrol. For these two you can set a minimum period between defragmentation runs. Multiple schedules can be created and you can view, edit or run them at any time with absolutely no trouble.

Review image Review image Review image Review image


The Space Management panel contains results and statistics on the amount of free space of all detected drives. The details provided present the amount of free and used space and the total size of each partition on the system. In order to increase the total of free space PerfectDisk can automatically empty the Recycle Bin or eliminate temporary files.

An additional instrument designed to help you get as much free space as possible is the duplicate finder, a not too sophisticated tool that can discover twin files on your computer. The tool permits defining the types of file the application should look for and compare, and it comes with some extensions of its own. More than this, the search can be limited to user-specific locations on a single drive.

Testing it showed that the engine rooting out the dupes can make a very thorough comparison job and in our case it did not miss even once. It simply detected the duplicates with no fuss and without requiring additional parameters, save for the location where to search for them.

Space Explorer, a component of Space Management, is the viewfinder into the arrangement and usage of files and folders on your drives. It is useful for navigating the file structure: hovering your mouse over the structure will show you the exact file stored in that section; and the context menu lets you open, delete or analyze a specific item (file or folder) directly from PerfectDisk. It provides an overall look at all the files occupying the drive. The largest items will be highlighted and marked on the file map.

The Space Reports instrument comes in handy if you want to see the predominant file types on a particular drive or graphs with files created, modified, accessed, or a top five of the largest items. It represents a good way to keep track of all the behemoths stored in a certain location without too much sweat. You can configure it to take into consideration files according to their created/accessed/modified date, their size or type.

Review image Review image Review image


Setting up PerfectDisk 10 is as easy as managing the options available in the interface. It is all a matter of better fitting your needs by providing finer tuning of the software. As the application brings to Windows its own services, which run in the background taking care that all tasks are carried out according to your wish and monitoring drives' idle times, there is no option for starting it with the operating system. You have on the other hand the possibility to set it to minimize to tray once Close button is pressed. Also, if the start splash-screen is more of a nag, you can disable it completely.

But this represents the lowest set-up level for PerfectDisk. More interesting options include the management of the files needed to start the computer (layout.ini), of the defragmentation while your notebook is on battery, or of how the missed defragmentations are cared for. In the same category are CPU priority settings and the way shadow copy defragmentation is performed.

Review image Review image Review image Review image
Review image Review image Review image Review image


PerfectDisk 10 is a heavyweight defragmentation solution providing a terrific set of options for gathering together scattered files on disk and regaining the read/write performance you should always benefit from. All the functions are neatly wrapped up in a shiny new GUI that gives easy access to all the options and completes reports on all jobs run.

It can be easily turned into a set it and forget it defragmenter due to the AutoPilot menu, which allows task planning seven ways till Sunday.

Besides the great drive optimization the application also supplies the necessary instruments to view a complete report on how space is used and see which are the most prominent files and file types. Additionally, the duplicate finder can greatly contribute to getting rid of useless data and increasing the amount of free space. It can start its job at drive idle times so that its impact on your work is minimal during the defragmentation procedure.

Active Directory management of PerfectDisk eases up the work of system administrators who no longer need to be aware of the changes of the groups as Active Directory will instantly recognize a new user and ensure that all members of the group have the application installed and configured according to the policy of that group.

The Good

PerfectDisk's technology ensures good quality defragmentation from the first pass. SMARTPlacement optimizes most used files for fast access while the other two defrag methods bestow consolidation of free space and simple defragmentation.

Pausing a task allows you to suspend its activity for an unlimited period of time and resume it later with no impact on the quality of the job.

You can view a log for any of the run tasks complete with time and date as well as details on the results achieved after its completion.

Scheduling options have been developed up to the point of defining the idle time delay for the defragmentation procedure to begin and setting a minimum period between defrag runs.

The Space Management panel brings a suite of instruments that will give all the information you need on the files stored on disk, their size, time of creation/modification. Duplicates Finder does a great job without having to configure entire sets of parameters for the findings to be 100% accurate.

The Bad

Estimation time for longer-term jobs is not at all accurate. It will modify repeatedly and not show accurate durations. In this case the only guidance you have is the completion percentage of the job and hope for the better.

It happened quite often that after analysis of the drive to get one fragmentation value and when commencing the actual process the application to start from a different one, always higher. This may be confusing for the users.

The Truth

An awfully good defragmenter that can, once configured properly, do its job completely unattended. It is an easygoing application that provides you with all the necessary tools and tips in order to take the best decision, but, most importantly, it does a great job optimizing the drives and gathering all file shards together.

PerfectDisk 10 managed to pull out a critical state drive with 93.6% fragmentation and increase its performance from 3.4% to over 99.7% in just a couple of runs.

It lets you perform both online and offline defragmentation so system files are taken care of as well. More than this, each file can be individually defragmented or you can add items to the ignore list for the software to avoid them during defrag operations and finish faster.

On the downside, there are still minor aspects to be revised in order to accurately show all the details and users to trust its statistics completely.

PerfectDisk 10 proves to be a reliable defragmenting companion for your system. It is highly flexible and easy to manage and thanks to the complete Help file it comes with you will have answers for all the questions regarding options, functions and how it all works.

Read PerfectDisk 2008 review.



EDITOR'S RATINGS:

User Interface: (5/5)
Features: (4/5)
Ease of use: (5/5)
Pricing/Value: (4/5)
Overall: (4/5)
  Final verdict: Very good   100% Clean Certified

TELL US WHAT YOU THINK:

27,940 hits · 17 comments · Link to this article · Print article · Send to friend · Subscribe to news

MUST-READ RELATED ARTICLES:


Pure Defragmentation

2008's First Defragmentation Release

Piriform Defraggler - Keeping Those Drives Spinning

READER COMMENTS:


Comment #1 by: Quant2 on 26 Jan 2009, 22:29 UTC reply to this comment

Wow! I knew that PD can operate on disks with very low free space, but I never expected that this program will perform so well on a partition with just 18 MB of free space!


Comment #2 by: Jeffrey on 27 Jan 2009, 21:14 UTC reply to this comment

Have used PD for quite a long time and I am very pleased and satisfied with its performance. Have used others and they are no match for PD.
Thanks for making life easy where Windows is concerned.
Keep up the good work.
Thanks again.


Comment #3 by: Peter Posetti on 27 Jan 2009, 22:19 UTC reply to this comment

A first class product which I put to regular use- it is so easy!


Comment #4 by: KB on 28 Jan 2009, 02:34 UTC reply to this comment

I was set to buy Diskeeper but then discovered that it had activation. Luckily, I discovered PerfectDisk which did not have activation and have been happy with it since.


Comment #5 by: Ron Staniszewski on 28 Jan 2009, 06:37 UTC reply to this comment

I was an avid Diskeeper user until I first tried Perfect Disk v6.0.... I've used it ever since. It's ease of use, speed and reliability win hands down over the competition. Version 10 is definitely worth the price...


Comment #6 by: Joel Hall on 28 Jan 2009, 13:55 UTC reply to this comment

I used to use Perfect Disk when I had a Dell and it was easy to use. But now I have a Power Mac running Windows XP on Apple's BootCamp and Perfect Disk will not work with it, as confirmd by Raxco's tech support. You should point this out in your review. Raxco points the finger of blame at Bootcamp but Windows own native defragmenter - a barebones version of Diskeeper - as well as more advanced versions of Diskeeper works with my computer just fine. When Raxco cares enough to fix their incompatibility, I'll come back.


Comment #7 by: Leon Villarrubia on 28 Jan 2009, 15:44 UTC reply to this comment

I'm running Perfect Disk 10 on a new Macbook Pro with WindowsXP on Apple's BootCamp with no problems at all.


Comment #8 by: George on 28 Jan 2009, 16:26 UTC reply to this comment

I have been with Perfect Disk products for a while.
PD 10 is an improvement, but still takes a couple of runs to make a perfect disk. Its' decision making programs in moving files and free spaces need to be dialed in a bit.
But it is worth the expense to own and use.


Comment #9 by: Mike on 28 Jan 2009, 18:37 UTC reply to this comment

I am still using version 8 on my small home network.

I use it along with ASC softwre which also has defragmentation capability among other features. They work great together as long as you don't use the smart defragging capability on ASC.

Every couple of months or so I run a little progam called "sramble". It scrambles your entire drive. Then I run Perfect Disk. By running scramble fisrt Perfect Disk has to defrag the entire drive. It takes a while but the results are great.

I also run Perfect Disk on reboot about once a month this defrags certain files (Meta) that are not done when running Perfect Disk while Windows XP is running.

Bottom line with Windows XP and a small home network there is absolutely no need to upgrade beyond 8.0

Comment #9.1 by: Keith on 30 Jan 2009, 17:45 GMT

Mike: I've been looking for a utility to scramble / fragment a partition. Is that little "scramble" program you use available?


Comment #10 by: svs95 on 28 Jan 2009, 22:05 UTC reply to this comment

I agree with this review, except I would say the "bad" is a minor issue. When has Windows ever correctly estimated file copy time? Windows file copying engine is the (ultra-safe) technology at the root of PerfectDisk, so that's probably the reason. However, as the reviewer pointed out, the percentage numbers should help you monitor progress adequately.

I find PD v10 to be a very worthwhile upgrade to previous versions. It seems like a much more "finished" product now, and StealthPatrol works extremely well now! Very easy on the system to let it do it's thing automatically.


Comment #11 by: Dennis Bach on 04 Feb 2009, 02:33 UTC reply to this comment

I was amazed at the speed of this new version. I no longer have left-over problems showing up after the scan, it complted everything! Very good looking and easy to get around in. Well worth the purchase if someone is in need of a good program such as this.


Comment #12 by: Stephen on 10 Feb 2009, 20:08 UTC reply to this comment

I have only used the demo version for about 10 days now, but I too have seen different results on different screens. One screen says that pagefile.sys has 0 fragments, another screen says it has 3 fragments. What's up with that? This is after I have run the pre-boot stand-alone defragger.


Comment #13 by: percuma88 on 14 Feb 2009, 21:42 UTC reply to this comment

Keith: (Comment #9.1) You can find the small utilities at http://www.perfectdisk.com/pd10-product-updates, under Tools, "Fragmentation generation/drive scrambling tools", and it's only 31,579 bytes.

Definitely PD v10 defrags much faster than previous version by almost 30%.


Comment #14 by: JoBales in Dallas on 07 Jan 2010, 08:54 UTC reply to this comment

I wanted to comment that this review was right on target. I've used Diskeeper for years but was disappointed that the price had jumped on their latest product. Times being what they are, I decided to look around at what other defragmenters are available. After reading quite a few positive reviews on PerfectDisk 10, I decided to try out the 30-day trial they offer. The software was completely operational, no features turned off until you pay up. The install went smoothly on Win 7 64-bit Home Prem edition. The software interface was easy to understand - I didn't feel overwhelmed with information but, like the ribbon in Office 2007, the PerfectDisk 'ribbon' makes it easy to locate additional features. Having been used to Diskeeper for nearly 10 years, I felt PerfectDisk seemed slow the first run. However, when finished I did find a noticable decrease in software loading time and disk access seemed more responsive. From there I did the Boot Time defrag which really did a good job organizing info on the disk. OH, and each time I ran a defrag, I noticed it finished faster than the one before so the program did move around a lot of information on the disk that first run. There are a number of usable reports that I found provided easy-to-understand information about what had just taken place. I can't say how pleased I was with the software. In addition, Raxco provides quite a few White Papers on their website. I found quite a few interesting and I came away with a little better understanding of the defrag process. At this point I was ready to take the leap, dump Diskeeper, and install PerfectDisk 10 on my systems. Price is very reasonable with PerfectDisk 10 Home edition at $29.95 and Professional at $39.95 (a $20 decrease from Diskeeper Pro's $59.95 price tag). Keep in mind these are PerfectDisk's regular price. If you've downloaded their trialware and provided your e-mail, you'll generally get regular offers for a discount. For instance, I took advantage of an offer where I got 20% off the price of PerfectDisk Professional and will be able to upgrade to the PerfectDisk 11 version as soon as it becomes available. Overall, I paid $31.99 and will get the free software so I'm very happy. Finally, I dropped a line late one night to Raxco advising how happy I was with PerfectDisk. The next morning I had a message from a ProductManger thanking me for my input. Later it turned out she passed my comments on to others in management who sent a personal e-mail thanking me for my comments. This may seem small but I'm normally used to sending in a comment to a software company and occassionally I'd get canned answer back. Raxco makes me feel they're interested in our input. So to summarize, I'd recommend to anyone wanting a great defragmenter program for Windows (XP, VISTA, and Win 7) and who don't want to have to spend an arm & a let to purchase it, take a look at PerfectDisk 10, try the trial version and I suspect you'll be hooked!

Pros:
Ease on installation, Ease of use
Feature Set
Noticable performance increase after running a regular and a boot defrag
Price! MSRP is affordable, if you get one of their "coupons" it makes it even more affordable.

Cons: None. I only wish I'd found PerfectDisk 10 when it was first released instead of paying for the competitor.


Comment #15 by: Gyrolin on 28 Jan 2010, 06:00 UTC reply to this comment

PerfectDisk 10 is terrible. I just let it run a full ‘SMARTPlacement’ and it substantially decreased my drive performance and increased my free space fragmentation.

Stats:
Vista x64
8GB DDR2 Ram
All nonessential background programs were shut down during this run.

If you need proof, check these links:
http://i50.tinypic.com/2qbvv9z.jpg
and
http://i47.tinypic.com/2ev6u74.jpg

This program is ridiculously awful. I had such a horrific experience with this program that I’m placing this review on multiple sites.


Comment #16 by: Dan on 07 Aug 2010, 23:17 UTC reply to this comment

"SMARTPlacement is a finer way to control the data that should be accessed the fastest from a partition. It will actually move the file to the fast-access tracks of the hard disk."

And this means that files that deserve the fastest access will be placed near the middle of the platters, to minimize seek time (going to either edge of the disk results in longer seek times - but no difference in transfer times).

Hard drives are different than CDs, DVDs, and Bloo Ray disks. Hard drives contain the same number of addressable bits on the outermost edge (or cylinder) as on the innermost edge.

Copyright © 2001-2012 Softpedia. Contact/Tip us at

WindowsGamesDriversMacLinuxScriptsMobileHandheldNews

SUBMIT PROGRAM   |   ADVERTISE   |   GET HELP   |   SEND US FEEDBACK   |   RSS FEEDS   |   UPDATE YOUR SOFTWARE   |   ROMANIAN FORUM